Homes with good schools unaffordable on average wages, new study finds


Chicago rare metro with zip codes both hard and easy to afford


In some places, like Atherton, Calif., it’s basically impossible to buy a home in a district with a good school on an average wage.

Nearly two-thirds of U.S. zip codes with good schools are unaffordable to homebuyers making an average wage, according to a study released Thursday.

The real estate data firm RealtyTrac compared data on school test scores and affordability of homes in the same zip codes. It identified 1,823 zip codes that had at least one good school, defined as having 2014 test scores at least one-third higher than their state average. In 1,192 of them, RealtyTrac found average wage earners would have to spend more than one-third of their income to buy a median-priced home there.

Zip codes with at least one good school had median home prices nearly double the price in areas with none, RealtyTrac said.

The list of most unaffordable metro areas with a good school was not surprising: New York, Los Angeles, and San Francisco. The most affordable good-school list included Detroit, Phoenix, Miami and Charlotte. Chicago appeared on both lists, with 58 zip codes in the most unaffordable category and 172 zip codes for most affordable.

Home prices rose the same amount — 7% — from 2014 to 2015 in both categories, RealtyTrac said. But the similarities end there.

Buying a home in the least-affordable good-school zips is daunting. In Atherton, Calif., a median-priced home served by Encinal Elementary would cost $6 million, 412% of an average salary. Buyers would have to pony up 202% of an average salary, or $1.18 million, for a home in the Brooklyn zip code where P.S. 29 is located.

But in some of the most affordable good-school zip codes, average wage earners would pay strikingly low amounts. The zip code including Whittier Elementary in Harvey, Ill., would cost homebuyers just 2% of wages for a $21,000 median-priced home. A median-priced home near Brandeis Elementary, in Louisville, Ky., would cost 3%.

Realtors told RealtyTrac that the hunt for a home with good schools is tougher than ever now, with such tight inventory across the country.

Lydia Creasy, a Denver-based broker with RE/MAX Alliance said buyers in desirable markets have to be especially pro-active and ready to move quickly when new homes hit the market. “In some cases buyers in these neighborhoods have either had to settle for a less-updated or smaller home or increase their price range.”

By: AndreaRiquier

Compare listings